Were you always an atheist? Were you at one point in time a Christian, Muslim, Jew, etc.? What made you stop believing?

I'm sure we could all give voluminous answers to why we don't believe in a personal god including, but not limited to: Personal, philosophical, scientific, historical, etc. reasons; which are all perfectly valid. But I want to know what spurred you to question your former beliefs and become an atheist.

Views: 632

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

A++ in succinctness. :)
I've always been fascinated by religious/metaphysical questions. As a young person I went to one church after another trying to find answers to my questions. None of the churches I visited were able to address them. Eventually, in my teens, I became involved in a Pentecostal church. I became a youth pastor and was not only very involved but an ardent believer.

By the time I was 20 I lost my enthusiasm for the Pentecostal movement and converted to Catholicism (I really did get into the music and pageantry). When I left the Army at 25 I intended to enter seminary. At the same time I was reading Thomas Merton, which lead to reading Alan Watts, which lead to realizing that what I appreciated about religion had nothing to do with god. Examining my beliefs, I concluded I really didn't buy the god concept at all. The mysticism still attracted me, but I hardly needed a church membership to explore that.

For a while I identified my beliefs as Buddhist, then later admitted to myself that I was an atheist. Theists had failed to present sufficient reason to suppose their gods, or any god, existed.

Just for fun and to provide a real ministry to the atheistic community, I got ordained by the ULC. So I'm a legitimate atheist minister. I even put up a website (reverendjackcarlson.com) where I can expand on my belief in non-religious spirituality.

Now I've been an atheist for over 30 years and know that this is what I am in regards to theism.
I'll throw my hat into the "raised quasi-Christian" (Catholic for me) ring, and also as one who never really swallowed the consecrated Kool-aid. The sticking point for me, though, was a strong belief that faith in something was better than a lack of faith. This took me well into my 30s to shake free of, and it's just been within the past 2 years or so that I've been able to freely call myself an atheist. Better late than never, I suppose. :)
Hi y'all - sorry but the question is spurious. We were all born atheists!
Yes we were all born atheists...

However that doesn't always sufficiently answer the question: why?

[funny icon by the way, is that you?]
I think it answers the question why! Religion is man made and it is not indoctrinated into children until they develop the capacity to absorb it and write it virtually indelibly on their sub-conscious. Children born of Muslim families in Iran are unlikely to become Christians - parents indoctinate their kids.
Were you ever indoctrinated into a belief system, if so, what made you change your mind?
I used to regularly attend church with my parents. I think this was probably the beginning of a long process that led me to where I am today, as I never really had a say in the matter and was discouraged from questioning the "powers that be".

In high school, I gained a bit more freedom from my parents and was able to stop and question why I supposedly believed what I was being fed, and I decided that I didn't buy into the whole Jesus thing, but the idea of some higher power seemed possible. I dabbled in Judaism for a while, but the more I learned about it, the more I realized that it was just like any other religion. Over time, the more I thought about it, the less sense the idea of some invisible entity made to me.

I guess I can't really call myself an "atheist" per se, as I don't think the existence (or lack thereof) of some higher power can be scientifically proven or disproven, although I can confidently say that I don't personally believe in one. On second thought, I guess that is probably atheism after all. At any rate, I can't really judge others for believing whatever they decide to believe. It's the ones who try to push their beliefs onto others that get to me (and that includes atheists as well... I've met quite a few extremely pushy ones).

At the end of the day, whether you're a Christian, Jew, Muslim, Hindu, Buddhist, Atheist, Agnostic, Zoroastrian, Scientologist, Mormon, or whatever, as long as you don't try and tell me what to think, we can get along.
It sounds like you would be called an "agnostic atheist" or "de facto atheist." They are only names anyway, call yourself whatever you like. Freethinker, Bright, Secularist, Secular Humanist, Rationalist, etc.

I don't believe in a personal god, or anything other superstitious nonsense, but I have to admit you can't prove there is or is not a god. Just like you can't prove gravity, and you can't prove that there isn't an invisible pink unicorn or flying spaghetti monster. The only proof you'll find for anything is in mathematics.

Science is 99.9% true. Just as I am 99.999999% sure that there is no god. But I don't want to say "I know there is no god," but only because I lack the proper proof.
In order for it to be possible, it must first be defined coherently. Can you do that?
not with god
Then why say you are "99.999999% sure"? ;)




Update Your Membership :



Nexus on Social Media:

© 2018   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: The Nexus Group.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service