Aberingi's long-running topic entitled "Do we need a Universal Atheist Symbol?" leads me to ask "Do we need a Universal Atheist Motto?".

Well, perhaps we don't, or perhaps we could, but some theists might get deservedly irritated if we chose to use something like "In Darwin we trust" at appropriate moments.
These words, suitably translated into other languages, have a basic international atheist appeal with respect to truth and helpful anti-theist sabre-rattling and debating.
e.g. they might look good on the side of a bus/ coach.

Views: 1606

Replies to This Discussion

True. The self is a discontinouous and fleeting function of being.
Yet, that's all I have to interact with existence.
I vote for Vales
you feel well in latin
We don't need a motto - we need a bunch of slogans that we can put out there, in order to get our message across. I am kinda partial to this though:

Religious people believe in a whole host of heavenly beings;
Atheists maintain a faith in themselves, and the hallowed grounds of reason and science.
A universl motto, probably not. I fear looking like a fundamentalist. I would however, like to see some tolerance towards athiests. We are seen in a very negative light. For some reason people in my region seem to relate atheism with satanism.
If I were to say I am Rhonda, I take in abused farm animals and give them a forever home, or I have spent the last three years of my life devoted to caring for my mum who recently died from cancer; they would see me as a kind, caring human. If I add in the fact that I am antitheistic, they overlook anything productive I have done in my life and view me as evil immediately. I would love to see our image changed.
My first thought is that it should be latin like carpe deim. I don't know why. It kind of reminds me as a battle cry like "Remember the Alamo". What ever it is I think it should have the light of being civil.
I personally like Stephen Hawking's quote:

There are so many aspects of science that have influenced my thinking that I wouldn't want to only focus on Darwin. Also, even if tomorrow Natural Selection and/or evolution was found not to be the way life progressed, I wouldn't automatically start believing in religion. I would start looking to science to find a better explanation. What about "in Science we trust" or "in reason we trust"?
Religion is to morality, as Lawyers are to the idea of justice.

(BTW, take a look at Religious indoctrination, and the harm that it does, when you get a chance.)
I really don't think a motto is necessary. Non believers already understand that we as atheist do not believe in a supreme being. In addition, they know that we believe in evolution, and not creative design. It just seems very pop culture to tag any motto in relation to atheism. We are who we are, and believe what we believe.
I see your point in this. As we have seen by all of the comments (mind included), there are plenty of good ideas. But I guess we still want to be known and heard at the same time. Rather than a chosen slogan, let the work being done with the billboards and recent bus stop ads show who we are and keep them coming so that all can see. I do like the idea of a universal symbol though.
I don't really like the idea of having a universal atheist anything. It's too similar to religion and gives the religious ammunition against us. Saying "In Darwin we trust" would just go to 'prove' creationists right that evolution is a religion and we all have faith in it rather than god.

Atheists come from all walks of life and have all sorts of political, philosophical views. Remember that not all atheists accept evolution. It's rather presumptuous of us, the skeptic/humanist/scientific naturalist community to impose OUR views on other atheists who may well have totally different values. I would certainly be annoyed if some of the chavs who reject religion just 'cos it sounds stupid decided "Religion is gay" was a universal atheist motto.

What we do need are more slogans like Carl Sagan's "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence". Dawkins is good at coming up with these, so is Christopher Hitchens. Slogans like these are usefull in debates and casual conversations with theists. "In Darwin we trust" just comes across the same way as saying "In God we trust" which doesn't really add much compared to "Science flies you to the moon, Religion flies you into buildings".

RSS

© 2018   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: The Nexus Group.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service