I'd love to see that moderated debate, I'll lurk in the shadows and if I am unpleased with the outcome, I'll start beating the same dead horse again in another thread.
Seriously though, I'd like to see that moderated debate happen. I always like a good debate, it would take a lot of time and effort to organize it though, something about herding cats and atheists springs to mind.
Isn't there some set of ground rules that can be set by moderators, I'm sure it would be easy to use a set of rules used in formal debate as practiced in Universities?
Would there be censorship in the moderated debate and would this still be published, possibly containing commentary? More importantly who would be the judge?