Plan to compile a database of theist questions for atheists and our responses



Several of us from a number of atheist organizations are planning to put together a database containing the most frequent and most difficult questions or challenges that theists put to atheists along with our most cogent responses.  To collect as many of these questions as possible, I am asking the members of various freethinker organizations to forward to me the most frequent or challenging questions or accusations that theists have confronted you with. Please also send your responses to these along with some key words to the subjects so that they will be searchable by fellow atheists. Also, if you have suggestions as to how we can restrict access of the planned database to only freethinkers, please include your strategy for that. 

This is one way that we atheists, scattered as we are, can use our internet resources to significantly help each other.  When we keep illuminating the absurd logic and farfetched arguments of theists, we strengthen our position and make them start thinking like the rational and ethical people they really are.  Thanks for all your help!

Eric Stone, PhD
Westchester Atheists

Views: 266

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Great question.  We need a brief response to it.

Something like "your definition of atheism is a religious one - we atheists don't accept religious definitiions"

Here's one that's comes from believers and right-wing atheists:

"As an atheist, haven't you just replaced god and religion with State and government?"

'tards worship.  Atheists don't "worship" anything,much less state and government. We participate in them, and follow laws for the same reasons everyone else does:  we get in trouble if we don't.
I reply, " I don't know anyone who worships any state or government unless they're forced to".

My previous reply apparently got lost in the system somewhere so I'm repeating:

 

State and govt are human-made and can be abolished by humans (usually via votes sometimes revolutions).  God and religion are not.

There is also the tendency for religious folks to define atheists as 'anti-religious' when we can more simply define ourselves as 'without religion'.  Not that I can't find reasons to criticize the things people have done in the name of Jesus/Allah/God/Yayweh/etc, etc, fill in the blank with supernatural belief system.  But not every atheist is a 'militant atheist', correct?

 

Atheists can see why a belief system may rationalize individual behavior, provide a sense of belonging/comfort and conclude that it has good and bad components, right? 

I have trouble countering the argument that religion keeps people from fearing death.... countering that (in my opinion) false sense of security that heaven exists in the afterlife.   Who am I to call a person silly or irrational for a belief that keeps them from suffering from existential crisis? 

Can I just point out that it's a little arrogant to think that you can speak for atheists as a whole and answer questions as if atheism was some kind of monolothic entity?

Feel free to add your own answers.

After spelling monolithic wrong I don't think I can take being asked serious questions.

 

But seriously, I was trying to make a serious point: atheists have vastly different philosophical, political, social and scientific perspectives so the idea that someone (or even a group of people) can make an "Atheist FAQ" is a quite weird one. Just me adding my opinion wouldn't make it that much different.

 

Whenever I see people talk about what "we atheists" think, it makes me a little nervous. It makes me feel like I signed up to a clique where others get to speak in my name.

I guess what I'm getting at is that right at the top of the list it should point out that these answers are by no means gospel, and that nothing guarantees that all atheists (or even a majority of atheists) adhere to it. It's just a collection of opinions to give theists an idea how these arguments might be answered by your average atheist.

 

And I don't mean this in a disrespectful way at all.

Of course, Park.  We're trying to compile lists of those provocative questions theists have or are currently posing to each of us or to the public in general so that we can be prepared to respond effectively.
Great!  We're at a fairly rudimentary stage now and have only about 60 questions.  But one thing we're thinking of doing is to divide the questions/challenges into logical categories and to also group the atheist responses to each question into quick and slow or analytical.  If you have any ideas of how better to organize or present them please advise.  If you send me your email address (mine is es35@nyu.edu), I'll forward our current spreadsheet.

Just saw that at PZ Myer's blog:

 

Ah, "stumper" questions. My favorites of all time:  

  5. "How did males and females evolve separately? Hmmm?"

  4. "So what happened before the big bang, hmmm?"

  3. "So why is the Bible's order of species creation in Genesis correct, hmmm?"

  2. "Who made you, then, hmmm?" --moment of sadness: this one came from my own mother.

  1. "Then how does this chair, which weighs 10 pounds, support a  pastor like me, who weighs 300?" --I offered to answer him, because I  know the physics of that, and he said, "No, that's not the point..."

  Of course. Getting an answer never is the point; the point is that they don't really want to know.

http://scienceblogs....comment-4081241

RSS

line

Update Your Membership :

Membership

line

line

Nexus on Social Media:

line

Latest Activity

Patricia posted songs
22 minutes ago
Patricia commented on Richard C Brown's group learnerscoffeeshack
1 hour ago
Plinius commented on Richard C Brown's group learnerscoffeeshack
1 hour ago
Patricia replied to Vangelis's discussion Same Sex Marriage in the group Politics, Economics, and Religion
1 hour ago
Plinius commented on Ruth Anthony-Gardner's group Hang With Friends
1 hour ago
Plinius commented on Ruth Anthony-Gardner's group Hang With Friends
2 hours ago
kathy: ky commented on Ruth Anthony-Gardner's group Hang With Friends
2 hours ago
Joan Denoo liked Teresa Roberts's blog post Do Nice Guys Still Finish Last?
2 hours ago

© 2017   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: Richard Haynes.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service