The relevant [?] state law [which has no place in a secular government that purports to uphold freedom of expression!] defines "desecration" as "Defacing, damaging, polluting or otherwise, physically mistreating in a way that the actor knows will outrage the sensibilities of persons likely to observe or discover the action."
So let’s say an adult (subject to harsher penalties than minors) elected to spray paint “Jesus loves dicks” on the side of this boy’s school. That guy, at most (... for people with previous criminal records ...), would serve a year in jail – and that’s assuming the cost of having the wall re-painted exceeds $150 ...
But a 14 year-old does something stupid that causes literally zero property damage and he could face two years in juvenile jail because it’s a “venerated object”? That’s insane. That’s really ludicrous.
If he had spray-painted the statue, I’d be all for charging him. If he had done any damage, he should be punished in accordance with the damage done. Hell, I even think a slap on the wrist for trespassing could be appropriate. But fucking with a kid’s life for being immature ... is petty, vindictive bullshit. This law about venerated objects needs to be challenged and unmade, and I hope this case can be a vehicle for that.
(ellipses and emphases mine)
Yeah - I totally give the kid points for cleverness.
Pennsylvania doesn't want me on the jury. I was laughing my ass off when I saw the photo.
Seriously, don't we have better things to do with the American Justice system than engage in "Oh, my poor, poor feelings are so hurt."
How many times have I said it, Pat?
No one, No One, NO ONE Has The Right NOT To Be Offended!
Sadly, if this thing gets shut down, as it should, the religious-right will probably turn it around and try to use it to get anti-bullying laws struck down ... because direct, personal abuse intended to terrorize a specific person is absolutely the same as something like this.
Lets see.......... I think you've said it 5281 times, including this time.
But it needs to be repeated until the tyrants are defeated.
Physically mistreating? What the hell? I mean, if he had caused damage, sure. Then a fine and some community service would be perfectly appropriate. The sensibilities phrasing is also kind of fucked.
This thing needs to be taken to a higher court, where the law can be struck down. Let us know when this thing gets anywhere in the courts, if this doesn't get thrown out right away. If there are any sane judges in the jurisdiction, it won't even see an actual trial.