Funny. I'm an atheist monk. :-)
Ohhhmmmm brother Taran
It looks like you have a puppy. How can you feel alone?
Yeah, worse than 80%, and then a good chunk of the remaining 10% to 15% are closeted. Makes them hard to find.
There's likely to be some critical flaw with 98% of the prospects out there. Case in point, even ignoring the severe attractiveness deficit that would prevent me from being appealing to her, there's Katie's desire for someone who chases her. I don't play the chase-me game, so I wouldn't be a source of romantic stimulation to her ... or something along those lines. Then, there's the liberal/Libertarian mismatch, which wouldn't make it impossible, but difficult.
Found this online today and thought I'd throw it into the mix: http://en.nothingisreal.com/wiki/Why_I_Will_Never_Have_a_Girlfriend
(The person who wrote it is an atheist with a sense of humor--check out the application to become his girlfriend: http://en.nothingisreal.com/wiki/Apply_to_be_Psychonaut's_girlfriend and scroll down to where he asks about "religious affiliation".)