The World's Largest Coalition of Nontheists and Nontheist Communities!

# Measuring The Distance To Very Distant Objects

I would really like to know how the Astronomers use "Red Shift", in the light spectrum,
to determine the distance to a very distant objects (see title).

The way I understand what the astronomers are doing is:

1. gather the light from a very distant object.
2. Pass the gathered light through a prism
3. Measure how far the red light has shifted. The more it shifts the farther away it is.

If this is where they stop their calculation of distance, to the very distant object , I feel
their calculations are only 1/2 to 3/4 finished.

I'll explain my reasoning and I will use numbers for distance and speed that make the math
much easier. You could use the actual distance and speed numbers and it would make no
real difference but you would need a calculator.

So...the numbers I will use are......10 billion lightyears to the very distant object and it is
moving away from us at 1Mph under the speed of light. Basically the speed of light.

This is how I see it.

1. Light leaves the very distant object 10 billion years ago on its trip to Earth and the
very distant object is  traveling in the opposite direction at the speed of light.

2. 10 billion years later the light finally reaches Earth but also the very distant object has
traveled at the speed of light for 10 billion years in the opposite direction.

3. In reality the very distant object is 20 billion light years away from us (right now) but
Astronomers can't see the very distant object at 20 billion lightyears because the light
from it hasn't reached us yet. It will though in 10 billion years

This make me wonder if the Universe is expanding, contracting or what. There is a large
gap in what the Astronomers are seeing and what is actually happening out there right
now. Possibly billions of years gap.

Whacha Tink

Peace

Views: 46

Tags: billion, distant, gap, object, quasar, speed

Comment

Join Atheist Nexus

Comment by exodia on June 29, 2012 at 5:57pm

There are actually two types of "redshift". Photometric redshift which estimates the distance of an astronomical object by way frequency shifts of photons.

And then there is the Einstein shift(gravitational redshift) which determines the distance of an astronomical objects like singularities(blacks holes) by way of frequency shifts of emitted electromagnetic radiation from a strong gravity field.
But the math is a bit more complicated than what is found in Hubble's law which determines the velocity of object relative to earth.

- Exodia

## Support Atheist Nexus

Nexus on Social Media:

## Latest Activity

Ruth Anthony-Gardner added a discussion to the group Feminist Atheists

### Sexism requires dehumanising women

23 minutes ago
36 minutes ago
Ruth Anthony-Gardner posted a discussion

### White male Atheist authority's invisible dimensions

46 minutes ago
The Flying Atheist, Ruth Anthony-Gardner and 2 other members joined Joan Denoo's group

### Solar Technology

1 hour ago
The Flying Atheist replied to Joan Denoo's discussion Epicurious's Myth-Busting Guide to Cooking Beans in the group Food!
1 hour ago
Ruth Anthony-Gardner added a discussion to the group Wildlife

1 hour ago
1 hour ago
2 hours ago