Some time back, I was watching a conference on YouTube, featuring some notable high-end audio equipment designers. What does that have to do with atheism, you might well ask. Well, one of the designers present, in talking about design theory and best practices, made mention of being “skeptical” of these standards, and then he dropped the following bombshell:

In a battle between theory and the real world, the real world always wins.
-- Kevin Hayes, VAC

I don’t know whether Mr. Hayes is an atheist or not, but his statement reflects a refreshing orientation toward what works as opposed to what doesn’t. The world of high-end audio is a rather odd place at times, where small changes can make big differences and where the rules aren’t necessarily fixed and adamantine. The only real bottom line recognized is the quality of the sound, and the final arbiter is not some piece of sophisticated measurement equipment, but the human ear. That is the “real world” which Hayes and his fellows work toward satisfying.

In retrospect, high-end stereo isn’t much different from religion as it comes to the vagaries of just what constitutes “good sound,” and it has more than a couple schools of thought, even as belief systems do. There’s tube and solid state and hybrid designs, Class A, Class AB, and Class D architectures, single-ended versus push-pull and so on. All of these are striving for the same goal: to take the source material, whether it’s vinyl, CD, reel-to-reel, or digital file and recreate the original performance from it.

There are multiple differences of course. The most important of these is reflected in Kevin’s statement above. Regardless if someone is a tube or transistor partisan, there is a goal to be reached: recreation of a live sonic event. By comparison, the believer’s desire to understand or know their deity has no “real world” to refer to. Their god is in no ways in evidence, so what results may be as many different models of gods as there are people.

But there is the music to listen to, and that puts audiophiles light-years ahead of believers. When they can produce a deity to interact with, let me know!

Views: 38

Comment

You need to be a member of Atheist Nexus to add comments!

Join Atheist Nexus

Comment by Loren Miller on January 6, 2019 at 10:20am

We each have something that works for us, Michael.  I got into the high end when I could afford it.  These days, I'm lucky I can maintain my existing equipment, but the music it continues to make makes it worth it.  It's something very real to me.  Yahweh and his BS?  Not so much.

Comment by Michael Penn on January 6, 2019 at 10:16am

What is the Ultimate Experience? I am not on a quest for it. My thing is to make myself happy first, then others fall in place for this after me. That's because I live in my mind and not theirs. Concepts of a "brain in a vat" only became popular once people came up with the idea.

As for music high tech, I can't afford it. I use My Tuner radio, Pandora, etc. and other modern apps for my music interests. I hear radio from all over the world and do it live.

Comment by Loren Miller on January 2, 2019 at 11:00am

Tell you what, Frankie: the whole "brain-in-a-vat" ain't my thing and isn't likely to be for a while, if ever.  Further, while in such an artificial state, I would wonder at means that could be brought to bear to examine "reality" such as it was and potentially reveal its problematic nature.

As it comes to music, though, when I'm not listening to The Cleveland Orchestra, I'm of the solid-state, push-pull, dual-differential architecture school of thought, and so far, it's worked pretty well.

Comment by Frankie Dapper on January 2, 2019 at 8:56am
  1. We are not far off from interacting with our God's. With the help of artificial intelligence it will soon be possible to have sex with Jesus and in that way make beautiful music with the Holy One or if you are a Hindu perhaps monkey business with the monkey god...

   2. Even scientist or lay persons with a scientific bent can find the Ultimate Experience....the big bang transforming Alice in wonderland theory into engineer pragmatism of working experience.

© 2019   Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: The Nexus Group.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service